CommentStreams:495f4e03856b4cf92a9a29904c70f355

What happens if the green messenger scores 3 points for a road, the red scoring meeple scores 4 points for a city and the green scoring meeple scores 6 points for a city, and the blue robber share the same space with these 3 figures?

a) The blue robber can rob only from the green messenger or the red scoring meeple.

b) The blue robber can rob from one of all these 3 scoring figures.

"Since both the green player and you chose to score your cities second with the same figures, the blue robber could not get half of the points from either city. The blue robber could only choose to rob the first green points or your first points available. If, however, the green player had scored the city with the green scoring meeple, the blue robber could have robbed half of those points, since that would have been yet another scoring figure to choose to rob from."