All Comments

Jump to: navigation, search
Comment Page Associated Page Comment Title Comment Author Last Editor Created Last Edited
CommentStreams:5f73a126e2040f4f5d8561e571cfd434 The Catapult (1st edition) Hi Corinthiens13,

The original wording was misleading for both the Knock-out and the Seduction tokens.... "Within" is referring to "on all the tiles" related to these features or special areas. Updated the wording and added more details to the clarifications about both tokens (Footnotes #4, #6 and #7).

Thanks for the heads-up. Hope it is clear now.

Cheers!

Meepledrone Sep 18 at 1:57 pm
CommentStreams:1184e133b12ea81e1fd639af83a598a4 The Catapult (1st edition) Is this a mistake, or did I miss something? Hi,

Footnote 6 says "This means that followers within the school, City of Carcassonne, and Wheel of Fortune can be hit and removed." Ok for the City of Carcassonne and Wheel of Fortune, but... How can there be a follower within the school ? Only a teacher may be on a school, and that's not a follower? Regards, Corinthiens13

anonymous Sep 17 at 8:11 pm
CommentStreams:Cb72a5445a6ba6f01b11d020e7491316 Main Page/ro I've added the NoTitle extension. As MeepleDrone proved that the current solution we thought to use didn't worked as planned. Please use it only where necessary. Sinscerly Sep 11 at 9:26 pm
CommentStreams:7ec6420dfce789dc9be7efa05ecc874f Main Page/ro The skin is removing the title on the default version of Main Page ... I'm checkhing why. Main_Page/en works the same as Main_Page/ro showing the page name as usual. Meepledrone Meepledrone Sep 4 at 10:51 am Sep 4 at 10:53 am
CommentStreams:B3add05078f8de7d3b85ab214ee95379 Main Page/ro To hide the title of this page. Here it is hidden. Carcassonne93 Sep 4 at 12:39 am
CommentStreams:9e7402259ee0df883e7da3c93ba17329 Main Page/ro Why? What do you want to do? Meepledrone Sep 3 at 11:56 am
CommentStreams:56b6327712d7df80858434ec761b50c0 Main Page/ro NoTitle I need NoTitle extension for this page. Carcassonne93 Sep 2 at 2:31 pm
CommentStreams:8c56e456dc6d3380372beafa8c7e111f Scoring After the Game The ringmaster will score 0 points for the city but it will get those bonuses associated to the figure:
  • The ringmaster points for scoring a feature
  • The fairy 3-point scoring bonus

Bottomline, no matter the feature scores 0 points the ringmaster will be receive those bonus points it is entitled to.

You can check the rules here:

Meepledrone Aug 28 at 6:47 pm
CommentStreams:611526826ee58848764ec1d20187fd07 Scoring During Turn Sequence The Fortune Teller? Is it possible to include The Fortune Teller in the list?

Surely this is also a PnP like The Land Surveyors.

anonymous Aug 25 at 8:54 am
CommentStreams:292ac4956a8fde14d65e6beba4bd795a Scoring After the Game Bonus points What happens at the end of the game with a ringmaster if it is placed in a city with a cathedral and the fairy is next to it? Carcassonne93 Aug 24 at 6:23 pm
CommentStreams:A10627f15f6263723597e341574c1d11 Hills & Sheep Yes, according to the wording.
  • The Hills & Sheep rules indicates you may choose between two options, that is, you ("politely") must choose between two given options. There is no possibility to skip this selection.
Translation from German: "Whenever you expand the field where your shepherd stands by placing a landscape tile, you may choose between two actions [...]"
  • The Fruit-Bearing Trees rules tell you that you may choose one option out of two candidates. So the rules are not forcing you to pick one.
Translation from German: "If you have placed a Meeple, you may now perform one of the two actions below. [...]"
Meepledrone Meepledrone Aug 23 at 8:21 am Aug 23 at 11:15 pm
CommentStreams:08f9e3db5b4b39abf77ca284d5bcea3d The Fruit-Bearing Trees Yes, according to the wording.
  • The Hills & Sheep rules indicates you may choose between two options, that is, you ("politely") must choose between two given options. There is no possibility to skip this selection.
Translation from German: "Whenever you expand the field where your shepherd stands by placing a landscape tile, you may choose between two actions [...]"
  • The Fruit-Bearing Trees rules tell you that you may choose one option out of two candidates. So the rules are not forcing you to pick one.
Translation from German: "If you have placed a Meeple, you may now perform one of the two actions below. [...]"
Meepledrone Meepledrone Aug 23 at 11:11 pm Aug 23 at 11:15 pm
CommentStreams:6841633040e84fdd5e7e99e1e3dc28ba The Robbers You mean placing several robbers on the same space so they can steal from the same figure? If so, yes.

The only limitation is that your robber cannot steal from your scoring figures, so you cannot place your robber alone with your scoring figures. There must be always a scoring figure from an opponent on the same space so the robber can always be ready to steal points from someone.

Meepledrone Meepledrone Aug 23 at 5:23 pm Aug 23 at 5:28 pm
CommentStreams:Fede6cb140e391c17f7b020ccd695fb2 The Robbers I wanted to say "The robbers can be placed next to the same scoring figure?". Carcassonne93 Aug 23 at 4:21 pm
CommentStreams:F64ce140a0d9fa95a6156b0408010aef Game Reference Added missing bonus. Thanks! Meepledrone Aug 23 at 4:14 pm
CommentStreams:1f7c943ab433127d5bc04a5a69dee5ac The Robbers If you mean the same scoring figure as the one the robber stole points from last time, the answer is yes. There is no limitation in this case. The only restriction is that a robber has to be placed on a space with at least one opponent's scoring figure. Meepledrone Aug 23 at 3:46 pm
CommentStreams:B39acae3bce4affb9b97cd31e50c9759 The Robbers The robber can be placed next to the same scoring figure? Carcassonne93 Aug 23 at 1:31 pm
CommentStreams:A898002868dd432a33e01c742b5681f0 Game Reference Fields "Score all end-of-game features taking into account the fairy and the ringmaster"- for fields, also the Tanners quarter. Carcassonne93 Aug 23 at 1:19 pm
CommentStreams:Ba4ce345c24cff6335a49b63552a9df9 River Correct. The pig-herd is a modifier that affects all the farmers scoring for the field. Meepledrone Aug 23 at 8:29 am
CommentStreams:F6f80f02e2ff2ab48e3f1ee0e1502683 Scoring During Turn Sequence The order of scoring is not strictly specified in the rules. You only know that when completing a road withe watchtowers and tollhouses, you will score all these bonuses before scoring the road itself. It is up to the player to decide the order applied, especially if, for example, robbers are involved. Meepledrone Aug 23 at 8:26 am
Next