Talk:La Porxada (1st edition)

House Rule suggestion questions

Do we need to confirm that although the Porxada city is considered incomplete under option 2, the option to score as complete at the end also applies to itself?

What order do players follow to choose whether to remove or leave followers if option 2 is chosen? For example, either starting with the player with majority, then minority (or reverse order?), or starting with the player who closed the city, and working clockwise? Or something else?

Slack Discussion : Meepledrone

There are no official clarifications as far as I cam see at the moment. I assume that all these questions will have to be resolved by house rules (edited)

I would assume, in order to be consistent, that note #1 applies to option 2 and the city with La Porxada will be scored at the end too.

Regarding the order of removal by the players will have to be agreed among the players: you can offer a list of options to choose from... the players can decide, for example to honour the player who placed La Porxada tile or the one who closed the city by letting players starting from his/her left-hand side in clockwise order to remove any of their followers, being the honoured player the last one to decide.

Clarifications to option #2

Oriol Comas, author of La Porxada, provided some clarifications in 4/2019 to the open questions regarding option #2 (bonus for all players with knights in the city containing La Porxada when completed). See next post for details:

Post with clarification from 4/2019

--Meepledrone (talk) 22:42, 16 April 2019 (UTC)