All Comments

Jump to: navigation, search
Comment Page Associated Page Comment Title Comment Author Last Editor Created Last Edited
CommentStreams:A05366ea273a0c462a995841d5e507fb Castles in Germany/ro "luminaries" What does it mean? Carcassonne93 Carcassonne93 Jun 4 at 11:14 pm Jun 4 at 11:14 pm
CommentStreams:71885f24414936b4bebe2edcfc33d1f3 Count, King and Robber Shrines "Shrine tiles cannot be placed adjacent to more than one monastery, and monasteries cannot be placed adjacent to more than one shrine. Shrine tiles are otherwise placed normally." It is not mentioned nothing about what happens if the tile surrounded with red was the tile A.

Heretics C2 Example 01.png

Tile A

Tile A

Carcassonne93 Carcassonne93 Jun 4 at 9:37 pm Jun 4 at 9:38 pm
CommentStreams:314c3d7d130069a772796ee59a1f5618 Bridges, Castles and Bazaars "An unoccupied monastery is considered completed:
  • The monastery does not score points by itself
  • A castle may score points for it
  • No player may score the Bookbinders district bonus"

Why a castle can and City of Leipzig can't? The Bookbinders quarter can score unoccupied monasteries.

Carcassonne93 Jun 4 at 4:05 pm
CommentStreams:E9118c32bd69056c5742ef3f7ab31185 The Farmers Big meeple "Similar to roads and cities, if there is more than one farmer in the same field, only the player with the most farmers in that field scores its points. In the case of a tie, each tied player scores full points." The big meeple? Carcassonne93 Jun 4 at 11:44 am
CommentStreams:495f4e03856b4cf92a9a29904c70f355 The Robbers What happens if the green messenger scores 3 points for a road, the red scoring meeple scores 4 points for a city and the green scoring meeple scores 6 points for a city, and the blue robber share the same space with these 3 figures?

a) The blue robber can rob only from the green messenger or the red scoring meeple.

b) The blue robber can rob from one of all these 3 scoring figures.

"Since both the green player and you chose to score your cities second with the same figures, the blue robber could not get half of the points from either city. The blue robber could only choose to rob the first green points or your first points available. If, however, the green player had scored the city with the green scoring meeple, the blue robber could have robbed half of those points, since that would have been yet another scoring figure to choose to rob from."

Carcassonne93 Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 10:55 pm Jun 4 at 9:53 am
CommentStreams:C6ff16d019a1bab40eec8543c1df00c4 The Robbers The correct order is "First, your messenger scores 3 points for the road. After that, the blue robber robs half of the points from the your messenger (2 Points.). Then your scoring meeple scores 6 points for the city. ", not "First, your messenger scores 3 points for the road. After that, your scoring meeple scores 6 points for the city. Then the blue robber robs half of the points from the your messenger (2 Points.)". Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 9:36 pm
CommentStreams:A65e936ad3b1b7731b1a8c658153da13 The Messages The rules of this expansion are very laconic regarding its interaction with expansions. We will have to fill the gap with the information available:

In this case, footnote #16 (http://wikicarpedia.com/index.php/The_Messages#cite_note-16) mentions this:

"If a tile is added to a feature with a builder and triggers the drawing of Message #4, The Message extra tile comes before the builder extra turn. If the extra tile from the Message is put on the builder's feature, this will create another builder extra turn. Thus, the events would be: initial turn => Message #4 turn => Message #4 builder turn => original tile's builder turn. (11/2013)"

This gives us a hint that Message #4 provides an additional full (nested) turn, since it can become a double turn.

There are no restrictions specified, so you may place any tile in your supply (German castle, abbey or halfling tile) as indicated in the Order of Play.

I'll add a clarification

Meepledrone Jun 3 at 9:06 pm
CommentStreams:41b8d8ac3fd089499527b138b3ca6ed2 Bridges, Castles and Bazaars The Markets of Leipzig rules state that:

"Bookbinders quarter: For each scoring of a completed monastery (as well for monasteries of other players) you get 4 bonus points."

...so, if a special monastery cannot be completed our to the presence of meeples placed as abbots, Bookbinders quarter can be triggered.

You ca revisit the rules here: http://wikicarpedia.com/index.php/The_Markets_of_Leipzig#Scoring_during_the_game

Meepledrone Jun 3 at 8:48 pm
CommentStreams:7c6cc1fc2a2f3999b7ccb0161e6e601e The Robbers The Robbers#cite note-9: "the robber must move with the figure rather than staying behind." It is obligatory to move the robber? Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 8:43 pm
CommentStreams:582abae9aa8c3cfa610ca06172fd3d3c The Barber-Surgeons Obligation You are obligated to place a meeple when you place a Bathhouse tile? Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 7:50 pm
CommentStreams:D1603b9b34c6e0ee9b9ad53566d492f8 The Robbers Order Which is the correct order, if the turn order is red, blue, yellow and green?

a) You place the robber; blue moves the robber; yellow does nothing; green place the robber.

b) You place the robber; green place the robber; blue moves the robber; yellow does nothing.

Carcassonne93 Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 6:52 pm Jun 3 at 6:52 pm
CommentStreams:E41c1cb7c085137724dbd24e42b5d888 The Watchtowers Final scoring It is not mentioned nothing about final scoring. Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 5:52 pm
CommentStreams:2fc2a3c20b9d7157c3813fbaf7fc993d The Barber-Surgeons Final scoring It is not mentioned nothing about final scoring. Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 5:51 pm
CommentStreams:3b7d333f67ee031972335b07b72e2927 Mage and Witch "If both magic figures are already placed, then they must be moved, following the same rules as for placing them." Only one figure must be moved.

"The magic figures do not have to be placed on or moved to the tile you just placed." But you can place a magic figure on the tile just placed?

"If you cannot place or move either magic figure (because there are no eligible locations), you must remove one of them from a tile and set it aside." "from a tile": It is not mentioned what happens if neither magic figure is in play.

Carcassonne93 Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 4:26 pm Jun 3 at 4:47 pm
CommentStreams:F231b2ca94ef07b17138c91fb3884d2b Count, King and Robber From the market to a field It is not mentioned nothing about "When you place the last tile (ending the game), the player to your left must remove one of his or her meeples from the market to one of the fields. This process continues in turn order until all meeples in the market have been removed and placed in a field. If the count is in the market when the last tile is placed, no meeples are removed." and "At the end of the game before final scoring, score the circus one last time." Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 1:43 pm
CommentStreams:D123fe48f611738b53d79bdc99440228 The Watchtowers More meeples It is not mentioned what happens if there are more meeples on a watchtower tile. Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 11:57 am
CommentStreams:4b519ea15a6c8679ad1f0c9a183fa632 Under the Big Top Total "for a total of 13 points." You receive 5 and 8 points. Not 13. This is important for messages. Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 11:53 am
CommentStreams:97fa97db8b5d91e6789b6b1aa2d27a1d The Messages The Messages#cite note-16: "If a tile is added to a feature with a builder and triggers the drawing of Message #4,". Whose builder? It is not mentioned. Carcassonne93 Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 10:35 am Jun 3 at 10:35 am
CommentStreams:A2721048df9dfd289b2b4b60a67bef86 The Robbers 3 players-game: The black robber is on blue scoring meeple and red scoring meeple. Is red's turn. Red remove and score the the red abbot (in 2B-1). The blue's flock is scored automatically (due the closure of the field) (2C).

a) The black robber can rob only red's points. b) The black robber can rob both red's points and black's points.

Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 10:21 am
CommentStreams:9fce38d790fae489b9559f4d89ad5f92 The Messages "Message 1: A road with an inn on it is worth 0 points if it is incomplete.

Message 2: A city with a cathedral in it is worth 0 points if it is incomplete." Why it is mentioned "if it is incomplete"?

Carcassonne93 Jun 3 at 9:49 am
Next